Is Non-Hierarchical Polyamory the Relationship Dynamic for You?

If you’ve found that monogamous relationships aren’t for you and you struggle to find your place in traditional polyamorous relationships, non-hierarchical polyamory might be the answer.

This relationship dynamic allows you to enjoy a romantic, sexual relationship with your partners without having to find your place as a primary or third. 

We’ve broken down non-hierarchical polyamorous relationships to help you find out if this dynamic could work for you.

What is Non-Hierarchical Polyamory?

Non-hierarchical polyamory is a type of polyamorous relationship where all partners are treated equally, and no single relationship is prioritised over others.

This differs from hierarchical polyamory, in which one relationship, often called the ‘primary’ relationship, is more important or has more decision-making power. 

At the same time, other romantic partners are a secondary relationship.

In non-hierarchical polyamory, partners aim to balance their time, energy, and emotional investments without ranking relationships.

This approach fosters equality, respect, and mutual support, creating a network of relationships where each bond is valued for its unique contributions.

Is it Different from Solo Polyamory?

Solo polyamory refers to a relationship style where individuals maintain autonomy and independence while engaging in multiple romantic relationships.

Unlike non-hierarchical polyamory, which focuses on treating all partners equally within a network of connected relationships, solo polyamorists prioritise their personal freedom and often do not seek to integrate their lives fully with their partners’.

They may choose not to cohabit or share finances with their partners, emphasising self-reliance and independence. 

This can result in a more flexible and unstructured approach to relationships, where personal goals and individual growth take precedence over forming interconnected networks.

It’s About Respect, Not Influence

Non-hierarchical relationships are centred around the belief that all partners are equally worthy of respect and consideration.

In this dynamic, no one partner automatically takes precedence over another simply due to the relationship’s nature or duration. 

Instead, decisions and commitments are made collaboratively, ensuring that each individual’s needs and boundaries are honoured.

This approach fosters a balanced environment where all connections are valued for their unique contributions, eliminating the pressure for any one relationship to dominate.

Do Non-Hierarchical Dynamics Go Against Our Nature?

But what about our instinctual nature? Society and the animal kingdom are rife with hierarchies that define the order of things, from who gets the biggest bite of the kill to who’s in charge. 

Aren’t we all just animals at the end of the day?

From a biological perspective, humans, like many animals, exhibit various social structures. 

In the animal kingdom, some communities, such as wolves or ants, have clear hierarchies with dominant leaders and subordinate members, while others operate more cooperatively and share responsibilities equally.

Among primates, our closest relatives, social systems vary widely. 

For example, bonobos have egalitarian social structures with prevalent cooperation and mutual support, whereas chimpanzees often have more defined social ranks.

Social flexibility in human societies demonstrates our adaptability and cultural diversity. While some cultures have historically emphasised hierarchical relationships, others are known for their communal and non-hierarchical practices.

Non-hierarchical polyamory aligns with these latter traditions, promoting equality and balance within relationships. 

Thus, while hierarchical systems are common, they aren’t the only natural order, and non-hierarchical dynamics also reflect our social capabilities.

The Dynamic of Relationships & Friendships in Non-Hierarchical Polyamory

For many people, romantic relationships are held in higher regard than platonic relationships with friends. 

This distinction in importance is often based on the fact that the relationship is romantic or sexual in nature.

For people who practise non-hierarchical polyamory, their friendships aren’t seen as lesser than their romantic relationships and vice versa. Instead, all relationships are valued equally and given the same level of importance.

Although this is unusual for allosexual or alloromantic people, it can lead to stronger friendships, as there is no expectation that one person fulfils all of their partner’s emotional or social needs. 

Non-hierarchical polyamory allows for a more diverse support system, with different partners and friends fulfilling different roles in an individual’s life.

Allosexual Definition Allosexual describes individuals who experience sexual attraction to others. Unlike asexual people, who may lack sexual attraction, allosexuals have sexual desires and often seek sexual relationships. The term differentiates between those who experience sexual attraction (allosexuals) and those who do not (asexuals), providing clarity and inclusivity within human sexual orientation.

Alloromantic Definition Alloromantic refers to individuals who experience romantic attraction towards others. Unlike aromantic people, who may not feel romantic attraction, alloromantic individuals seek and desire romantic relationships.

Does Non-Hierarchical Polyamory Lead to Relationship Anarchy?

Non-hierarchical polyamory and relationship anarchy share some similarities, such as rejecting traditional relationship hierarchies and emphasising autonomy.

However, non-hierarchical polyamory still acknowledges distinct, intimate relationships and their dynamics. 

In contrast, relationship anarchy goes further by refusing to label or define relationships at all, treating all interactions as equally valid without predefined roles or expectations.

Therefore, while non-hierarchical polyamory allows for structure and individual preferences within its framework, relationship anarchists aim for a completely fluid and flexible approach to connections.

Non-hierarchical polyamory doesn’t inherently lead to relationship anarchy but can share underlying principles of equality and autonomy.

How to Know if Non-Hierarchical Polyamory is the Dynamic for You

If you’re unsure whether the simultaneous relationships of non-hierarchical polyamory are the right relationship dynamic for you, consider these things to help you understand yourself better before you plunge into a new relationship.

Can You Imagine Yourself in a Non-Hierarchical Dynamic?

It’s crucial to reflect on whether you can envision yourself in a non-hierarchical dynamic because these relationships require a commitment to equality and balance. 

Understanding your comfort level with this framework helps determine if you’ll thrive emotionally and socially.

This introspection ensures that you are not just accommodating but genuinely compatible with the dynamic, thereby fostering healthier, more fulfilling relationships.

Evaluating your potential role and happiness within non-hierarchical polyamory can prevent misunderstandings and conflicts, leading to stronger and more supportive connections.

How Co-Dependent Are You?

One of the most important things to consider is your level of co-dependency within your romantic or sexual relationships. 

This is the main thing that’s likely to make non-hierarchical poly relationships difficult for you.

Here are some questions to ask yourself… Do you rely heavily on your partner for emotional support and validation? How comfortable are you with spending time alone and pursuing your interests independently? Do you often find yourself needing constant reassurance from your partner about your relationship? Are you capable of making major life decisions without feeling the need to consult your partner first? Do you feel uneasy or insecure when your partner spends time with other friends or partners? How do you handle conflicts and disagreements within your relationship? Do you seek resolution independently or rely on your partner to steer the outcome? To what extent does your self-esteem depend on your partner’s opinions and feelings about you? Can you set and maintain personal boundaries in your relationship without feeling guilty or fearful of rejection?

Are Non-Hierarchical Polyamorous Relationships Right for You?

Non-hierarchical polyamorous relationships attract those who value equality, autonomy, and diverse emotional connections. 

They create an environment where each relationship is respected and nurtured without predefined rankings.

However, this dynamic isn’t for everyone. It requires significant self-reflection to determine if it’s a good fit. 

Understanding your own needs and comfort levels with non-traditional relationship structures is crucial for making an informed decision that aligns with your happiness and well-being.

You can find out more about ethical non-monogamy, polyamory, and more with the Illicit Encounters blog!

FAQs