Claire counted them, in the end. Not deliberately — she was scrolling back up the thread on a Thursday evening looking for a delivery code, and she kept scrolling, and there it all was. Twenty-two messages between her and her husband since breakfast. Bins out tonight. Boiler man coming between 12 and 4. Have you got Ella’s boots. Tesco won’t do the slot, shall I do Saturday. Thumbs up. Thumbs up. Thumbs up.
Twenty-two. Before six o’clock. She sat on the edge of the bath, phone in her hand, and thought: we are in constant contact and I have not had a conversation with this man since roughly the spring.
The household runs. That’s what makes it so hard to see
Most people, asked whether they communicate well with their spouse, reach for the evidence they can see. The shared calendar. The WhatsApp thread that never goes quiet. The fact that neither of you has missed a parents’ evening in nine years and the car tax has never once lapsed. By any reasonable measure, the two of you are a functioning unit.
And that’s the trap. Because fluency in admin looks exactly like closeness from the outside, and often enough from the inside too. Couples who barely speak can still exchange forty messages a day. The volume goes up while the content quietly empties out, and because nobody’s gone silent on anybody, there’s no obvious moment to point at and say: something’s missing here.
Compare it with the marriages people worry about — the ones with the slammed doors, the fortnight-long sulks. Those at least announce themselves. A logistics marriage never does. It just gets more efficient every year.
Nobody asks a question they don’t already know the answer to
Here’s the test, and it’s an uncomfortable one. When did your husband or wife last ask you something they genuinely didn’t know the answer to? Not what time you’ll be back. Not whether you’ve rung your mother. Something about what you think, or what you’re worried about, or what you’d do with a free Saturday and nobody to answer to.
Gareth, 53, from Cardiff, described it almost apologetically, as though he was complaining about nothing. “We talk all the time,” he said. “She’s not cold. She’s not cruel. She just hasn’t been curious about me in about eight years, and I don’t think she’d know what I meant if I said it.”
He only noticed because of a work trip to Leeds, and a woman on the next table at breakfast who asked what he actually did all day, and then asked why he’d chosen it. He talked for twenty minutes. He said he felt slightly drunk afterwards, at half past eight in the morning, on nothing but being asked.
Why it gets worse with competence
There’s a cruel logic to the way this develops. The better you get at running a life together, the less you need to actually talk. Early on, everything requires discussion — where to live, whose family at Christmas, how you both feel about the mortgage. Twenty years later all of that is settled, automated, absorbed into the routine. The decisions are made. The system works.
Children accelerate it enormously, and then leaving home accelerates it again in the other direction, which catches people out. Plenty of couples discover in their fifties that the kids weren’t just the subject of most conversations. They were the entire reason there were any.
So you end up with two people who know precisely how the other takes their tea and nothing whatsoever about what’s going on behind their eyes. Familiar without being known. It’s a specific kind of lonely, and it’s astonishingly common.
What people tend to do about it
Some try to fix it directly, and good on them — a rule about no phones at the table, a Sunday walk where admin is banned, the deliberately awkward question over a second glass of wine. It works more often than cynics expect, though it takes a run at it rather than one attempt. One dinner won’t undo eight years of thumbs-up emojis.
Others find the conversation somewhere else entirely, which is where a great many of our members start. Not looking for romance particularly, and certainly not for drama. Looking for the experience of being asked something and having the other person wait for the answer. Rachel, 49, from Sheffield, said the thing that floored her wasn’t the flirting at all. It was a message that read: you mentioned your sister last week, how did that turn out?
Somebody had remembered. Somebody had wondered. That’s a low bar, objectively — and yet there are marriages all over Britain where it hasn’t been cleared in years.
If you’ve read this far and found yourself scrolling back through your own thread, you probably already know what you’d find. And you probably already know where to find illicitencounters.com.
Leave a Reply