“He’s my best friend.” It gets said at anniversary dinners, in wedding speeches, and to a friend over a second glass on a Tuesday night. It’s meant as the highest compliment a marriage can be paid. Twenty-odd years in, still each other’s first phone call, still the person you’d ring from a hospital car park. What could possibly be wrong with that?
Quite a lot, sometimes. Not always — plenty of couples are best friends and lovers both, and good luck to them. But we hear that sentence often enough, from people who are clearly aching, that we’ve stopped automatically taking it as good news.
Helen, 46, from Chester, offered it up almost as a defence when she first got in touch. “I’m not unhappy. He’s my best friend, honestly.” Four messages later, unprompted: “I just can’t remember the last time he looked at me like a woman rather than the person who knows where the passports are.”
How a marriage turns into a friendship without anyone deciding
Nobody sits down in year nine and votes to trade desire for companionship. It happens in increments so small that none of them would survive being written down. A baby, then another. A parent who gets ill in Doncaster and needs three visits a month. A promotion that eats the evenings. A mortgage that turns two people into a small logistics firm with a shared calendar and a running list of who is doing the Tesco order.
And the partnership gets brilliant at all of it. Long marriages develop a real competence — the shorthand, the loyalty, the way one of you handles the school gate crisis whilst the other handles the boiler. People who’ve never had that underestimate it badly.
But friendship has no upper limit on how comfortable it’s allowed to get. That’s rather the point of it. There’s no version of a best friend where you’d think twice about being seen in the ancient dressing gown, or where you’d bother making an entrance. Comfort is the reward. And a marriage that has quietly become a friendship keeps collecting that reward long after everything else has stopped being topped up.
The one thing a best friend can’t do
A best friend can be endlessly kind to you. A best friend can know your childhood, your worst week, the exact way you take your tea. A best friend will drive to Manchester at midnight if you ask. What a best friend cannot do — what they are more or less designed not to do — is want you.
And being wanted turns out not to be a decorative extra bolted onto a functioning marriage. For an awful lot of people it’s load-bearing. It’s the thing that made getting older feel survivable, the thing that made a body you’ve started avoiding in mirrors feel like an asset rather than an admin problem. Take it away slowly enough and you don’t notice the beam has gone until something starts sagging.
Here’s the cruel bit. You can’t complain about it. If he drank, or shouted, or disappeared every Friday, there’d be a word for that and a sympathetic friend to say it to. “He’s lovely and I feel like furniture” doesn’t fit on any form. Say it out loud and someone will tell you how lucky you are, and the maddening thing is that they’re not entirely wrong.
Why the good marriages ache the most
Danny, 52, from Reading, has been married nineteen years and describes his wife as the funniest person he knows. “We laugh all day,” he told us. “We just don’t touch. I can’t even work out when that stopped. And I feel like a complete arse for minding, because on paper I’ve got nothing to mind about.”
That guilt is heavier in a happy-ish marriage than in a miserable one, and it’s why so many people sit in it for years. A bad marriage gives you permission. A good friendship with a wedding ring on it gives you nothing but the sense that you’re being greedy for wanting one more thing on top of everything you already have.
You’re not being greedy. You’re describing a fairly ordinary human need that your marriage has stopped meeting, whilst continuing to meet a dozen others rather well. Both things are true at once, and pretending otherwise is what keeps people stuck.
So what happens next
Some couples get it back. It usually takes one of them being braver in a conversation than they want to be, and both of them behaving, for a while, like people trying to impress somebody. Others try that and find the friendship is simply what they have now.
And some people go looking for that one missing thing elsewhere — discreetly, without setting fire to a home they mostly love, and with no intention of losing their best friend in the process. That’s not a failure of character. It’s a fairly clear-eyed reading of what they’ve got and what they haven’t.
If you’ve read that and recognised your own kitchen in it — the good bits and the missing bit both — you already know where we are. IllicitEncounters.com has been the quiet answer for a great many people who’d never dream of leaving.
Leave a Reply