Three flat first coffees nearly made one IllicitEncounters member delete his profile for good. What he changed before the fourth date is advice worth stealing.
The third coffee ended the way the first two had: a polite hug outside a Costa in Knutsford, a “lovely to meet you,” and a message two days later that was kind but unmistakably final. Graham, 52, sat in his car in the retail park for twenty minutes afterwards, watching people wheel trolleys past, and thought seriously about deleting his profile.
He’d been on IllicitEncounters for two months by then. Twenty-three years married, two grown-up sons, an accountancy practice in Chester, and a marriage he describes as “perfectly pleasant and completely silent.” Joining the site had taken him the best part of a year to work up to. And now here he was, three dates in, wondering whether the problem was him.
It was. Just not in the way he thought.
The interview problem
Graham had prepared for each of those coffees the way he’d prepare for a client pitch. New shirt. Two rehearsed anecdotes — one about a disastrous golf trip to the Algarve, one about his sons. A mental list of questions so the conversation would never stall. On paper, he did everything right. He was punctual, he was polite, he insisted on paying.
And each time, the woman sitting opposite him met a man giving a presentation about himself.
“I was auditioning,” he told us. “I didn’t see it at the time — I thought I was being charming. But I never once said a thing in those three dates that I hadn’t already decided to say before I left the house.”
Here’s the thing about married dating that rarely gets said plainly. Nobody on the site is looking for a performance. They get performances at home — the cheerful voice for the in-laws, the “fine, thanks” over dinner, the smiling school-gate version of themselves. What most people are quietly hoping for is relief. The company of someone they don’t have to manage. A polished delivery of your best material is the one thing everyone in this position already has too much of.
The message he almost didn’t send
His fourth match was Rachel, 49, from Warrington. Married, one daughter away at university, a job in NHS admin she was funny about in a tired sort of way. They’d been messaging for a fortnight and it had been easy — easier than the others. Which is exactly why, the night before they were due to meet, Graham found himself sitting at the kitchen table mentally rehearsing the Algarve story again.
He caught himself doing it. And instead, at half eleven, he typed something honest: “I should warn you — I’ve had three of these coffees now and I’ve been terrible at all of them. I get nervous and turn into a man delivering a TED talk. If I start doing it on Wednesday, you have full permission to tell me to stop.”
She replied in four minutes. “Thank God. I’ve been practising sounding relaxed in the mirror.”
What an honest first coffee actually sounds like
The date itself, he says, started nervously anyway — the difference was that they could laugh about it. She pointed out his hand was shaking on the cup. He pointed out hers was too. Three hours went by in a café near Tatton Park, and not one rehearsed anecdote made an appearance. He told her he’d nearly deleted the whole thing after date three. She admitted she’d almost cancelled that morning, and had done exactly that to two other men before him.
That was February. It’s now five months of roughly-every-other-Thursday lunches, and Graham describes them as “the least performed hours of my week.” Not the most exciting, he’s careful to say. The least performed. From a man who spent two decades being pleasant and silent, that might be the bigger compliment.
But the lesson isn’t that honesty is a clever technique — the moment it becomes a tactic, it’s just another rehearsal. The lesson is that his three flat coffees weren’t a verdict. They were practice he didn’t know he was getting, with people who were busy performing right back at him. Most people’s first date on a married dating site is nowhere near their best. The site is full of decent, nervous people privately practising sounding relaxed in the mirror.
So if you’ve had a flat first coffee — or three — take it from Graham: it isn’t a sign you should stop. It’s usually a sign you’re still auditioning. And if you haven’t had the first one yet, well. You already know where to find us.
Leave a Reply