There’s a phrase that comes up at dinner parties, usually from someone in their forties or fifties who’s been married a decade or more. Someone asks about their relationship, and they smile slightly and say, “Oh, we never really argue these days. We’ve sort of figured each other out.” Everyone nods. It sounds healthy. It sounds, to most people listening, like a marriage that’s survived the rocky bits and finally arrived at calmer water.
But at Illicit Encounters, we know that if you look a little closer at the marriages where that phrase gets said the most, and a rather different picture starts to come into focus.
Why arguments aren’t actually the problem
Real arguments — the ones that erupt over how the dishwasher’s been loaded, or who forgot to text the school about the parents’ evening — are almost never about dishwashers or texts. They’re about feeling unseen. About suspecting the other person isn’t quite paying attention anymore. And the fact that someone bothered to start the row at all, to push back, to be visibly annoyed, means they still cared enough to want their partner to know.
When the rows stop, it isn’t always because two people have arrived at some serene Buddhist understanding of each other. Sometimes it’s because one of them — or both — has quietly given up on the idea that being heard is ever going to change anything.
Linda from Cheltenham put it neatly when she got in touch with us last spring. She’d been married 19 years. “We don’t fight,” she said. “We just don’t talk much either. The house is calm. It’s so calm I can hear the dishwasher hum.” That hum, she said, was the loneliest sound in the world.
There are two kinds of quiet marriage
There’s a quiet that comes from peace. And there’s a quiet that comes from withdrawal. From the outside, they can look almost identical.
In peaceful marriages, the silences are warm. The two people in them are still curious about one another. They still ask small questions, still tease, still notice when the other person comes back through the door. They might not have screaming rows about anything, but they aren’t avoiding each other either. They’ve worked out what matters and what doesn’t, and chosen not to escalate the things that don’t.
In withdrawn marriages, the silence has a different texture entirely. There’s nothing to disagree about because nothing’s really being shared. One partner stopped raising things because raising them led nowhere. The other partner read the new quiet as agreement and stopped checking in. Both then label the result “low-conflict” and tell people, with a small smile, that they’re lucky.
Trouble is, low-conflict doesn’t always mean low-loneliness. Quite often it means the opposite.
How to tell which one you’re actually in
The cleanest test isn’t whether you argue. It’s whether you still tell each other the small, useless things. Not “did you put the bins out” — the proper rubbish. The funny thing you saw on the way home. The colleague who was being weird at lunch. The new song you couldn’t stop playing in the car. If those little offerings have dried up, something’s drifted, even if no one’s slammed a door in months.
Here’s another one. When something good happens to you — a compliment, a piece of news, a moment of pure ridiculousness — who’s the first person you want to tell? If the honest answer is your sister, or a friend, or a colleague you’ve known for six weeks, that’s information worth sitting with. A marriage that’s still alive tends to be the first port of call for both small joys and small annoyances. When it stops being either, it’s usually because you’ve stopped expecting much of a response.
What people actually do about it
What we hear from members again and again is some version of the same thing. “I didn’t realise how flat things had got until someone new asked me how my week had been and actually waited for the answer.” It’s rarely the dramatic stuff that gives the game away. It’s the absence of small attention.
Some couples find their way back. They start asking again. They make a real effort to be properly interested in each other for the first time in years, and sometimes it works beautifully.
Others find that what’s gone has gone. The rows stopped because the wanting did, and you can’t argue your way back into being curious about someone you’ve stopped wondering about.
And then there’s a third group, the one we hear from most often. They stay in the marriage — the house, the children, the shared history all feel worth keeping — but they quietly start looking for the missing piece somewhere else. It’s the conversation most couples never have out loud. It’s also the conversation a lot of our members are already having with themselves long before they ever sign up.
So if a friend tells you proudly that they never argue with their husband anymore, take a second look before you congratulate them. Some marriages have made genuine peace. Others have just gone quiet because no one’s bothering anymore.
Leave a Reply