10 Red Flags to Look Out for When Dating a Separated Man

So you’ve met a man who’s charming, witty, and kind. It’s the happily ever after you’ve been hoping for. Except, you’ve found out he’s separated from his wife, and things are a little more complicated than you anticipated.

Don’t worry – we’re not here to destroy your dreams of lasting love. It’s perfectly possible for these relationships to develop healthily and without drama. 

But, there are some common red flags when dating a separated man that you should be aware of to avoid unnecessary heartache.

Whatever situation your new man finds himself in, keep an eye out for these red flags to protect your peace.

The Biggest Red Flags When Dating a Separated Man

Dating a separated man can be a wonderful experience that leads to a long-term love that has the potential to blossom into much more.

However, there’s no denying that these relationships come with additional baggage compared to dating someone who’s never been divorced or has been divorced for years.

So, it’s sensible to keep an eye out for these common red flags we see in separated men.

Red Flag #1 He Wants Too Much Too Soon

When dating a separated man, if he’s eager to accelerate the relationship prematurely, it can be a significant red flag.

This behaviour suggests he may be seeking to fill the void left by his previous partnership. To protect yourself and your well-being, it’s important to establish a foundation of trust and to understand each other’s individual needs and expectations.

A relationship that moves too quickly is likely to overlook these essential steps, which can potentially lead to complications and hurt feelings in the future.

Red Flag #2 He’s Vague About His Relationship Status

One of the biggest red flags when dating a separated man is that he’s ambiguous about where he stands in the process of his separation or divorce.

This lack of clarity is often a sign that he’s not fully ready to commit to a new relationship. If he’s still legally and emotionally entangled with his previous partner, there can be a lot of baggage involved.

When someone is evasive about their current relationship status, it raises questions about honesty and transparency, two pillars essential for a healthy, trusting connection.

Red Flag #3 He Has a Complicated Relationship With His Kids

A complicated relationship with his children can serve as a gigantic, waving red flag when you’re dating a separated man.

If he exhibits tension or unresolved conflict in his role as a father, it may be indicative of underlying issues that could affect your potential relationship. Children’s well-being is paramount following a separation. How a man navigates co-parenting and his interactions with his children can reveal a lot about his character and values.

Also, strained family dynamics could place undue stress on your relationship as you may find yourself entangled in these complexities. We’d recommend keeping a respectful distance from his family until you can judge the dynamics.

Red Flag #4 He’s Openly Jaded About Commitment

If your separated man is openly cynical about commitment, it can be a serious red flag. Such a man might express his distrust in long-term relationships or scorn the idea of marriage, drawing from his personal, perhaps painful, experience.

While it’s understandable, this outlook may prevent him from fully investing in a new relationship. It’s likely his scepticism could overshadow the potential for building a trusting and lasting partnership.

Red Flag #5 He Gets Defensive or Angry When You Ask Questions

When the separated man you’re dating doesn’t want to discuss his past relationship, it’s a sign he hasn’t fully processed everything that happened.

Acknowledging and reflecting on the past is a crucial part of personal growth and moving forward in a healthy manner. If he sidesteps conversations about his separation or previous life, it may indicate unresolved issues that can quickly become your issues if you’re not careful.

Red Flag #6 He’s Still Emotionally Involved With His Ex

Remaining emotionally attached to his ex-partner is a huge red flag that shouldn’t be ignored. The ongoing attachment between the two ex-partners could still be harbouring feelings for each other, and you’re just a rebound relationship.

While it’s normal for him to have some unresolved feelings about his marriage, a distinction must be drawn to protect your relationship. An honest conversation is required to ensure his feelings for his ex have settled into a platonic space so he can fully open his heart to someone new.

This rule shifts when children are involved, as maintaining a healthy co-parenting relationship often involves a higher degree of contact and emotional connection with an ex-spouse.

Red Flag #7 He’s Still Financially Tied to His Ex

Being financially tied to an ex can be a substantial red flag when entering into a relationship with a separated man.

This ongoing intertwining can signify that their past relationship still holds a degree of control over his present actions and commitments.

Also, financial obligations may lead to stressful situations, particularly if he’s not open about the nature of these ties. It’s important to insist on transparency in this area to understand how these financial responsibilities may impact your relationship.

Red Flag #8 He’s Reluctant to Seek Therapy for the Divorce

Therapy is thrown around a lot when it comes to trying to fix relationship issues. While it’s a great resource, you have to acknowledge it’s not for everyone.

With that being said, if he’s never tried therapy or counselling for his divorce, it doesn’t bode well for the future of your relationship. Relationship breakdowns are difficult, painful, and emotional experiences that need to be processed properly to move on healthily.

Be sure to take your time progressing with the relationship if he’s reluctant to take steps to deal with his emotional baggage before entering a serious relationship.

Red Flag #9 He Makes Comparisons Between You & His Ex

When dating a recently separated or divorced man it’s natural for him to subconsciously compare his relationship with you to the relationship with his ex. This is just human nature, and as long as it’s not vocalised, it shouldn’t be a problem.

However, if the man you’re dating frequently makes comparisons between you and his ex, that’s a huge red flag. Regardless of the progress of his divorce proceedings, being compared with another partner isn’t good for your mental health or relationship.

It also indicates that he might not be fully over his previous partner, or he doesn’t believe you tick all his boxes – in which case, you should dip out of the situation to save yourself a future heartbreak.

Red Flag #10 He’s Hesitant to Introduce You to His World

If the separated man you’re dating seems hesitant to introduce you to his friends and family, view this as a red flag. His hesitancy to integrate you into his existing social circles could indicate that he is not serious about the relationship or not ready to move forward with you publicly.

When someone is truly ready for the next chapter in their love life, they’ll typically be excited to share it with those close to them. This inclusion is a sign of their investment in the relationship with you and their confidence in its prospects for the future. 

Without this step, you might be kept in a holding pattern, leaving you feeling insecure and unsure of where you stand.

Advice for Dating a Separated Man

If you’re feeling a bit doom-and-gloom about your relationship now, don’t worry. Just because there are a few more red flags to look out for when dating a separated man, it doesn’t mean there’s no hope. Here’s some advice to help make your relationship run a bit smoother.

• Proceed with caution: Always remember that a separated man is going through a significant life transition, which can be complex and challenging.
• Communicate openly: Maintain honest and transparent communication about expectations, feelings, and the progress of his separation proceedings.
• Establish boundaries: Be clear about your comfort levels and establish boundaries, especially regarding his interactions with his ex and how they can impact your relationship.
• Self-reflect: Take time to reflect on your own readiness to be involved with someone who might not be fully available emotionally or legally.
• Look for progress: Pay attention to the progress he’s making in his personal healing. Is he moving on, or is he stuck in the past?
• Be independent: Preserve your sense of self and independence. It’s important for your well-being and ensures you’re not simply filling a void.
• Demand respect: You should feel valued and prioritised. If his actions don’t match his words, reassess the situation.

Read more advice on how to deal with the emotional difficulties of dating someone who is married but separated.

Summary: Is It Okay to Date a Separated Man?

Yes, it’s completely okay to date a separated man, but it’s key to recognise that this experience is markedly different from dating someone who isn’t so entangled with their ex.

While separation is a formal step toward ending a marriage, the relationship isn’t legally concluded, which can introduce a unique set of challenges. Dating during this transitional phase requires understanding and patience as both parties navigate the emotional and logistical obstacles inherent in the dissolution of a marriage.

If you choose to pursue a relationship with a separated man, do so with openness and realistic expectations, acknowledging that the path ahead may be less straightforward than with a partner who is completely unattached.

To get more advice on navigating complex relationship dynamics with separated, married, and divorced people, read more on our blog.

FAQs